Learning about photography through our world

登録

  • New Feature Release: Share your TrekLens photos with the world by posting a Photo Viewer Widget on your blog, website or favorite social network. [More Info] [Sample Viewer]
Featured Destination: Cluj, ルーマニア
Title: Reflection
Reflection (38) *
ciprian_miron Gold Star Critiquer/Silver Workshop Editor [C: 59 W: 17 N: ] (259)
Title: * Full Load *Sony DSC-H50
* Full Load * (38) *
CAROL50 Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Star Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 853 W: 113 N: ] (8960)
Over 525,331 photos from around the world
北アメリカ アジア ヨーロッパ Oceania 中央アメリカ South America Middle East Africa
Featured Theme: my flowers (25 photos) :: henri Lecaire (colvert) Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Star Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 847 W: 281 N: 1941] (10354) [Group Theme][view all themes]
フランス
Title: Bunch from BrittanyPanasonic Lumix DMC-FZ4
Bunch from Brittany (16)
colvert Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Star Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 847 W: 281 N: 1941] (10354)
フランス
Title: bumblebeeNikon D90
bumblebee (34)
colvert Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Star Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 847 W: 281 N: 1941] (10354)
フランス
Title: Prunus IINikon D90
Prunus II (8)
colvert Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Star Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 847 W: 281 N: 1941] (10354)
特集(アーティスト): martin attard (girbi) (29)
クロアチア
Title: that's lifeNikon Coolpix 5700
that's life (10)
girbi (29)
カナダ
Title: PostcardNikon Coolpix 5700
Postcard (5)
girbi (29)
アメリカ
Title: Kayaking
Kayaking (2)
girbi (29)
Featured Critique: Hugh Siegel (bombilla) Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Star Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 293 W: 54 N: 149] (1952)[view all critiques]

Great

It is a controversial photo, as someone pointed out. For me, its controversey lies in the the conflict between the intentions of the photographer and the effect of the photo. The intention to document a social problem in the hopes of changing it by raising awareness is a noble one. Would that were all to take such a photo every day, rather than just trying to please our own senses.

But, the problem with the photo, for me, is that it takes the social problem and turns it into a conventionally palatable work of art, a beautiful object to be consumed. The boy, even though he is smoking, or perhaps because he is smoking, looks good to me. He looks radiant almost. He's glowing, he's wearing a mischeivous smile, he's got a limpid light in his eyes. If I look more closely I see he's wearing rags, his fingers are filthy, and, yes, he's smoking. But still, the overall impression I take from this is of a beauty. The beautiful colors, the gorgeous light, the skin tone, the proportions of the composition, the frank gaze of the child.

Okay, sure, one could say those things are ironic. Maybe. (I don't think that's your intention Shogun, but let's, for sake of argumentm, say it is.) Maybe it's ironic that we like the photo, that it pleases us visually, and that it is a photo of a wretched impoverished kid. Maybe it's a kind of trick photo, designed to trip us up and play with our expectations. That's a critical point of view, yes. But that is also primarily an intellectual point of view. It is an artistic point of view. It is not a point of view that inspires action.

I like this photo because it is a deft portrait of a beautiful kid that captures his humanity. That is what is great about it. And it is unassailable from that point of view.

But as a call to action about the plight of kids -- the desperate, urgent plight of imporverished kids in our world, in your country and mine -- I think it's a failure. It leaves me with no anxiety. It doesn't compel me to get out of my seat and say "enough." It doesn't show the ugliness that we need to see to shock us out of our complacency.

So, that's why I think this is a controversial photo.

Best, -Hugh
フィリピン
Title: Kids Gone BadNikon D-50
Kids Gone Bad (64) *
Shogun Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Star Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 788 W: 52 N: 418] (10434)
Featured Favorite Photos[view all favorites]
カナダ
Title: Pourquoi ne m'avez-vous pas attendu ...Olympus C-740
Pourquoi ne m'avez-vous pas attendu ... (36) *
LaGrande Silver Star Critiquer/Gold Note Writer [C: 36 W: 8 N: ] (570)
アメリカ
Title: Kiss Of The Scarlet WomanToshiba PDR-4300
Kiss Of The Scarlet Woman (44) *
chiaraluna Gold Star Critiquer/Gold Star Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 421 W: 90 N: ] (1897)
ブラジル
Title: macro
macro (22) *
bucanas Gold Star Critiquer/Silver Workshop Editor/Gold Note Writer [C: 1671 W: 27 N: ] (12712)